Choose the sentence with correctly presented pronoun case in a prepositional phrase:

• A. She gave the book to John and I.
• B. She gave the book to John and me.
• C. She gave the book to I and John.
• D. She gave the book to John and myself.

Answer: (B)

The key idea is pronoun case after a preposition. After a preposition like to, the pronoun should be in the objective form. When there are two recipients joined by and, both should be in that objective case. So the correct version is to use John and me in the object form: to John and me. The sentence should read: She gave the book to John and me.

Using I after a preposition is incorrect because I is nominative, not the object form. Saying to I would sound wrong, and to I and John would also be incorrect for the same reason. The form myself is a reflexive pronoun and is used for emphasis or when the subject and object refer to the same person, which isn’t the case here.